Shingles vs Metal Roofing: Which is better for your Pole Building?


Shingles vs Metal Roofing

Post Frame buildings, often called Pole Buildings, are structures that can literally have thousands of uses for your home, business, or farm because of their storage capabilities and the great strength that makes them durable and long-lasting.

The Appeal of Pole Buildings

Shingles vs Metal Roofing

Apart from the tremendous utility of pole buildings, the aesthetic appeal is another factor in making them desirable as storage buildings, since they are available in an endless variety of configurations and color schemes, which means there is sure to be something available to suit every taste. One of the greatest appeals of pole buildings is the quick construction time and inexpensive cost when compared to traditional stud-wall structures. Yet their large load-bearing posts allow them to handle even greater loads. With fewer materials needed for support functions, pole buildings also have more interior space available for storage, so they can be very economical as well.

In terms of construction materials, there are good reasons for using either metal or shingles on your pole building. In the end, it comes down to which looks better. But the practical reasons for each should be considered.

Advantages of Metal Roofs

Shingles vs Metal Roofing


  • For all intents and purposes, metal materials are maintenance-free during their lifetimes and will not require painting or preserving.
  • Independent studies have shown a 20% reduction in energy cost with metal roofing because of emissivity. Emissivity is the materials ability to release absorbed heat.
  • Metal roofs are much lighter than shingles and engineered for strength and durability.
  • Metal will not rot, split, crack, break or curl up. Which is one of the reasons it generally requires no maintenance.
  • It is resistant to termites, pests, mold, mildew, dirt and the effects of aging from environmental influences.
  • Metal typically has a very long life expectancy, and rarely needs replacement, which makes it an economical choice.
  • Modern metal materials often consist of high-quality steel or steel substrate. Not the cheaper aluminum or tin from years past.

Advantages of Shingle Roofs

Shingles vs Metal Roofing

  • Shingles are easy to install without specialized tooling.
  • Shingles can be installed on an accessory building to match ones existing residential roofing systems.
  • Owners of shingled buildings often claim they are more visually appealing than the look of metal.
  • Shingle options are readily available in great numbers since it has been the most popular option for years past.
  • Shingles are easy to maintain.
  • Warranties can cover 20 to 30 years, so durability is assured.

Both materials have their strong points, and both will continue to be very popular for a long time to come.

Whatever your decision, post frame pole buildings offer a wide variety of uses. A home owner who is a recreation enthusiast might want to store a recreational vehicle in a pole building. A do-it-yourselfer would love setting up a workshop. A farmer might keep animals, farm equipment, or hay and straw inside their agricultural building. A business owner might find one of these buildings useful for storing office equipment and other supplies.

For more information on types of pole buildings and materials, visit


A Post Frame Building is the Most Energy Efficient Solution

A Post Frame Building is the Most Energy Efficient Solution

Post frame buildings are frequently an ideal solution for budget-driven decision-makers. Fewer materials, less labor, shorter time from design to finish, and more sustainable raw materials are the key drivers to creating a practical and less expensive structure.

Ongoing operating and energy costs are an essential cost element, as well.

Energy management must always be an important consideration for any building owner. Even with the most expensive, energy-efficient heating, cooling, and dehumidifying equipment available, some buildings require more energy per cubic foot than others to heat and cool while driving up annual operating costs unnecessarily. Architectural designers and builders strive to create an energy efficient building that’s also versatile, expandable and provides a broad span and wide access for multiple uses. Some methods do not fit the bill.

Post frame buildings have proven to be the best solution for fire stations, agricultural buildings, schools, medical additions, churches, municipal buildings, and even residences. These structures not only save money by using less energy but are also more budget-friendly overall due to the design-to-completion costs that are substantially lower than with other buildings.

How can a post-frame or pole barn construction be more energy efficient than other types of construction?

Let’s examine some other types of buildings to show the advantages:

Concrete Buildings

Concrete is unquestionably sturdy. However, the material has poor inherent energy-efficiency and insulating properties. Concrete, plus all of the additions like furring strips, stud walls, and external coverings required to meet fire codes, add to the construction costs while reducing the overall insulating capability. Constructing a concrete building is expensive from the outset and can be energy inefficient due to the many places where energy can escape.

Steel Frame Buildings

Another relatively popular option is steel frame construction. Since steel itself is a natural conductor, steel framing becomes a poor option for insulating the interior space despite its strength as a material for construction.

Framing in this manner requires insulation to be sandwiched between the outer steel and the framing. Insulation gets crimped in “waves” or small sections throughout the building due to the closely spaced conductive steel breaks. Compressing insulation reduces the R-value while the steel columns act as “power bridges”, transferring heat to the exterior during the winter. In fact, steel conducts heat 310 times faster than wood.

Post Frame Insulation: The Big Difference

The broad, 8-foot spacing between vertical supports of a post frame building provides a more continuous expanse of insulating materials. As a result, the installer is not required to “squeeze” the material between vertical beams nor are there as many energy-losing supports that conduct energy to the outside.

Wood is used in all of the parts of a post frame structure, including headers, trusses, and vertical support columns and framing. Since wood itself is not an efficient conductor of energy, the combination of widely spaced vertical wood beams throughout and high R-Value modern insulation material evenly installed between the beams reduces the volume of energy that would be lost in other structures.

Metal Roofing: Additional Energy Benefits

According to Pacemaker Buildings, the abundance of wood components in a post frame building creates an energy-efficiency superiority over steel framing and masonry or concrete block structures. Also “cool metal roofing” formulations add energy savings and have earned Energy Star Ratings.

Pacemaker’s Energy Package system teams superior insulation with efficient ventilation for a comfortable and cost-efficient environment.

Energy Efficiency and Sustainability

Individuals, civic leaders, corporations, and environmentally conscious community leaders have become more focused on protecting the ecology of the planet by recycling, reusing, reducing waste, and eliminating air, water, and ground pollution for the benefit of future inhabitants of the earth.

The concept of sustainability, in simplest terms, is to ensure that the resources of our planet are preserved and protected in such a way that those future generations may also live comfortably. Poisoning the atmosphere, tainting the world’s water supplies, and using up nonrenewable resources is not a means to protect future generations.

Let’s compare the sustainable nature of post frame construction with other types of construction.

Post frame construction uses a combination of highly renewable wood products plus easily recycled metal siding and roofing. While concrete, masonry, and steel framing materials are products that require significant energy to mine, dig, process, and transport. The extraction of the raw materials leaves irreparable blemishes on the landscape.

Trees grown for wood construction materials add positively to the atmosphere while replacements can be continually planted. Conversely, materials used for masonry and concrete are not renewable.

Saving on total energy usage is also an important sustainable objective. With more efficient insulating capability, post frame construction adds further to the sustainability of the planet.

Use a Professional, Experienced Post Frame Builder

The benefits of creating a well-designed and engineered post frame building are best assured when working with a professional company that understands exactly how the post frame systems collaborate to create a durable and energy-efficient structure. While post frame construction may appear to be simple compared to other methods (which it is), the process still requires expertise and precision. As with any building, precise execution without compromise is the only way to ensure long-lasting success.

Look for an experienced company like Pacemaker Post Frame Buildings to create the structure you need that will last a lifetime.

Post Frame Buildings: Built to Endure

Repeating the same steps unnecessarily is a waste of energy. Major construction projects must be performed with prolonged usage in mind. Concrete and bricks are difficult to repair once any substantial damage has occurred. Vinyl and other plastic sidings can be flimsy. Moreover, conventional steel buildings frequently find their way into the scrap pile.

Post frame buildings incorporate the enduring qualities of wood along with a sensible foundation construction to achieve more durability in high winds than other building methods. It doesn’t matter if the support beams are anchored in concrete piers with metal casings for longevity or incorporated into the building foundation. Post frame buildings are designed to withstand all that Mother Nature offers. Because the “diaphragm effect” directs the wind’s forces into the ground, post frame buildings have withstood tornado and hurricane-force winds which crumbled other structures.

Post Frame Buildings: Talk with the Experts

All of these factors mean lower energy cost and a better return on investment. Saving money on utility costs can be a tremendous saving and contribute mightily to the bottom line.

With these attributes and the inherent energy efficiency, post frame buildings are cost-effective, sturdy and labor-friendly – which means you save money without compromising.

For more information, visit the Pacemaker website or contact the experts at Pacemaker Buildings at 888.834.4448. Learn more about all of the advantages and benefits of this type of construction. One of Pacemaker’s dedicated staff will be happy to discuss your needs and any budget considerations for your new building.

Most Common Pole Barn Repairs

Most Common Pole Barn RepairsOver time, post frame buildings may need repairs just like any other structure. Upgrading may be essential for older buildings that were constructed without the newest technologies and materials that last a lifetime. However, even with the older structures, repairing or reconfiguring is easier than making similar repairs on conventional-type constructions.

Continue reading